+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 21

Thread: Why I hate Indonesian Bureaucracy

  1. #1
    Fanatic JohnnyCool's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    South Denpasar
    Posts
    592

    Default Why I hate Indonesian Bureaucracy

    I will try to be as level-headed as I can with this, although I'm seething with anger at the moment.
    Read on.

    My mother passed away in Australia last Sunday. I need to go there as soon as possible. I have a retirement Kitas and before leaving Indonesia, I have to get an "Exit Permit". My Indonesian wife will accompany me (she's been there before).

    The death is stressful enough, and running around organising things for a fast departure hasn't been easy. I've managed to do everything except for the "Exit Permit".

    I lodged it at the Immigration office in Denpasar yesterday. They told me it might be ready the same day, or "definitely" the next day. I'm still waiting. They told me a couple of hours ago that it will "definitely" be ready by three o'clock tomorrow afternoon. I "thanked" them for that but our flight is tomorrow night.

    This sort of stuff pisses me of to the max. Do these people really have no compassion or understanding whatsoever?

    In stark contrast, I got a multiple entry Australian Visitor's Visa for my wife in 15 minutes.

    I still have several things to do here before I go. I am not impressed by having to sit around wasting many hours waiting for some Indonesian Immigration idiot to get their act together and phone me (which they rarely do, by the way).

    Are Indonesian "officials" really that uncaring? It looks like it to me and I'm disgusted.

    I might be pushing the envelope too far but the way I see it, they couldn't care less if an expat suddenly has a problem back in their country. Do many Indonesians really see us only as walking money bags?

    I first visited Bali 37 years ago. I've been living here for about the last 16 years. These days in the South (where I live), every day is dance with potential death on the "roads".

    I am seriously considering leaving Bali and never coming back. Kind of had enough of the endless crap these days.

    Whatever "magic" Bali once had is being rapidly eroded, big time.


  2. #2
    Tourist
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Posts
    1

    Default

    LIKE THIS..These days in the South (where I live), every day is dance with potential death on the "roads".

    I am seriously considering leaving Bali and never coming back. Kind of had enough of the endless crap these days.

    Whatever "magic" Bali once had is being rapidly eroded, big time.

    I as well getting fed up w/ Bali and the quality life going down hill..Its way to hot all the time and to stressful doing biz.
    Check ur replys twitter. I sent u info citric acid.I also live Renon. Been here 20yrs..Follow me twitter so I can send u direct messages instead of coming here.
    cheers
    Nattoman

  3. #3
    Regular
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Bali + Vietnam
    Posts
    134

    Default

    I feel for the situation you are in JC....helpless. That is unless if you speed the system up the good (bad) ole way. Your morals may prevent you from doing this reading most of your posts.I too am having such feelings.Ive spent the last 5 months working for a company 41% owned by pertamina and 30% owned by the Suharto family. It was previously (up until 2008)* 100% owned by Pertamina. It was publicly listed then and the Suharto clan bought in.As such, its never done business using finance as a driver for sucess, only power and authority.ITs extremely nationalisitic, and despises having to use foreign expertise working in the public sector as it does now. As such, my usual work day consists of constantly being set up, having to take full responsibilty for things completely beyond my control, people accessing my personal details through HR dept and smsing my partner with all manner of horrible stories (blocking senders # of course), and a complete lack of co-operation even down to sabotage.Before anyone says...."well what are you doing there"?, well im not for much longer.Im walking away. Maybe even being fired before i get a chance (their always a month late with their pay so gotta be careful in the execution).* This short little trip into how big business in Indonesia is run has crushed a lot of the hope I had for Indo.I thought it was all being cleaned out!The corruption/beurocratic issues in Indonesia are not getting any better, not being adressed, and are actually on the rise with the push for national* economic and business recovery . Although it wont have enough effect to make me leave Indo (not immediately anyway), this little experience certainly has me checking my options.I'll certainly be trying to make sure my next contract is outside Indonesia. A month on at work here, and then "unwinding " here for a month has my gagging right now.Not meaning to publicly vent, but can somewhat sympathyze JC.

  4. #4
    Regular
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    ubud
    Posts
    194

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by JohnnyCool View Post

    This sort of stuff pisses me of to the max. Do these people really have no compassion or understanding whatsoever?

    Not, they donīt, I realised many years ago that compassion is not something familiar for many people here...

    Are Indonesian "officials" really that uncaring? It looks like it to me and I'm disgusted.

    Yap, they are that uncaring.......

    I might be pushing the envelope too far but the way I see it, they couldn't care less if an expat suddenly has a problem back in their country. Do many Indonesians really see us only as walking money bags?

    You are right they donīt care!! what I am not sure is if all these is just about money, I donīt think so, sometimes is just about their aptitude and way to see the things!!! hehehe thousands times since I live in Bali I though people has not feelings...............not the ones we use to have........



    I am sorry to hear all this JC, and I am really hope by now you have already the exit permit!!!!!!!!!! must be a very stressfull day for you leaving tonight.
    JC in a way I am surprise about all this, I mean your reaction, of course is normal, but what I mean is that after reading many of your post, I always though that you "know quite well" indonesian or balinese people and all the burocrasy system!!!!!!!! will never stop to surprise you isnīt it? and that can be really really tiring...........I agree with you is not an easy country to live...
    I have to do my own exit permit before 2th April and the agency charge me 600.000 Rp, I still thinking if will be worthy or not to pay or do it myself..............
    I hope all things went well for you today!!
    "Overcoming poverty is not a gesture of charity. It is an act of justice. It is the protection of a fundamental human right, the right to dignity and a decent life." Nelson Mandela

    http://www.kupukupufoundation.org

  5. #5
    Fanatic JohnnyCool's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    South Denpasar
    Posts
    592

    Default

    I always though that you "know quite well" indonesian or balinese people and all the burocrasy system
    I am not surprised by lax Indonesian officials, under normal circumstances! I am usually prepared to wait when I have to. I don't regard an important family death as something I have any control of.

    I finally got my Exit Permit at 3:15pm today, three days after I applied for it. Even so, I still had to protest a little about how long it was still taking. I think they got the message and they gave me discount of Rp50,000 (I paid Rp350,000).

    By the time I walked back to my car where my wife was waiting for me, she'd just received a phone call from the Immigration official telling her that I seemed to be a bit agitated/angry and that she should try and calm me down.

    Repeating myself, when the Australian Consulate learned of the reason why my wife needed a Visitor's Visa for Australia, it was issued on the spot within 15 minutes!

    We fly to Australia tonight.


  6. #6
    Regular
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Posts
    390
    Blog Entries
    10

    Default

    Sorry man to hear about this extra stress you definetely don't need.
    Good it's all been settled now. Hang on there.
    >> Pee - Poo - Pie - Pea - Nuts <<

    And the whole question is: are we really supposed to shave the planet...?

  7. #7
    Regular lumumba's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Bandung-Bali-Jakarta
    Posts
    351

    Default

    I’m sorry JC and condolences.
    I can’t remember if you already have the retirement visa (KITAP) or not, if you don’t the only way to avoid this is to apply for a multiple entry/exit permit right at the beginning (not cheap) when you apply for the visa, but than again why someone should apply b4 hand. Why do we need a BLOODY entry/exit permit? Money of course but then again the system should at least work.


    I am seriously considering leaving Bali and never coming back. Kind of had enough of the endless crap these days.
    I
    I do understand you 100% since I feel exactly the same way.


    Do these people really have no compassion or understanding whatsoever?
    Do many Indonesians really see us only as walking money bags?
    Without any doubts, but maybe will change in future and be worse for them.

  8. #8
    Regular
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Location
    Canggu
    Posts
    196

    Default

    Sorry to here about your loss JC. My father died last November, for immediate trips out of Bali(which is @8 times per year) I got a multiple entry business visa...to avoid the crap that you went through. When I organized my trip back to Oz for Dads' funeral, that was the easy part, the biggest hassle was family members agreeing on the funeral arrangements. Hope all goes well

  9. #9
    Addicted Markit's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Location
    Karangasem, Bali
    Posts
    1,867
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default

    JC sorry to hear about your loss but I have to remind you that any country where you have people paying for their jobs the same people must use the job to "earn" their livings.

    The problem that all expats have everywhere is that over time they tend to forget why they so happily left their homelands.

    If you haven't cooled down yet I suggest you take the opportunity while in Oz to just pop along to the housing department and ask what you have to do to get building permission for a house there or maybe register for a driving license. I've just picked these 2 examples at random for all I know they may not fit at all, but I'm sure you get my meaning.

  10. #10
    Fanatic JohnnyCool's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    South Denpasar
    Posts
    592

    Default

    Thank you all for the condolences, etc.

    We made it to Australia OK and with our newly acquired Indonesian tax numbers, didn't have to pay fiskal.

    Australia was sort of a breath of fresh air, mostly. Before I left Bali, I managed to renew my NSW driver's licence using the internet. (My licence had expired in September, 2008.) No problem so long as it's less than two years since expiry.

    I own properties there so applying for building permission is not an issue for me. For sure, Australian bureaucracy can be pretty mean, at times. But at least you can easily find and get the information required, unlike here in Bali or the rest of Indonesia.


+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 LastLast

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts